Busamen Gachi Fighter

Uglymug, Epicfighter

Characters

Shigeru Yoshioka

MAIN

Seika

MAIN

Seiji

MAIN

Rizu

MAIN

Uglymug, Epicfighter Season 1 Review: A Bold, Flawed Isekai That Dares to Be Different

Uglymug, Epicfighter (also known as Busamen Gachi Fighter), which premiered on July 6, 2025, on Crunchyroll, is an anime that swings for the fences with a premise that flips the isekai genre on its head. Based on Ryo Hiromatsu’s web novel and adapted by WHITE FOX, this series asks a provocative question: what happens when an unattractive, socially ostracized protagonist becomes an overpowered hero in a fantasy world without shedding his “ugly” exterior? While the show’s ambition and unique angle make it stand out in the crowded isekai landscape, its execution stumbles, resulting in a polarizing experience that’s equal parts intriguing and frustrating. Here’s a deep dive into why Uglymug, Epicfighter Season 1 is a fascinating, flawed experiment that pushes boundaries but doesn’t always stick the landing.

A Premise That Challenges Isekai Tropes

At its core, Uglymug, Epicfighter follows Shigeru Yoshioka, a former salesman whose life unravels after a false accusation of misconduct leaves him jobless and reclusive. Shigeru, self-described as “ugly,” leans into his insecurities by embracing his appearance in a new fantasy world, trading conventional attractiveness for godlike strength and abilities. Voiced by Junichi Suwabe, Shigeru’s journey begins when a suspicious PC link transports him to a realm where he’s both a powerhouse and an outcast, burdened with a unique weakness: physical contact with women causes him severe damage.

This setup is a refreshing departure from the typical isekai formula, where protagonists often transform into idealized versions of themselves. By keeping Shigeru’s appearance unchanged and making it a central narrative pillar, the series explores themes of self-worth, societal beauty standards, and the cost of power. The concept of an “ugly” hero who’s stronger than anyone but crippled by social stigma and a bizarre gender-based debuff is ripe for both comedy and commentary, positioning Uglymug, Epicfighter as a potential critique of superficiality in media and culture.

Strengths: Bold Ideas and Memorable Moments

The anime’s greatest asset is its willingness to take risks. Unlike most isekai, which lean heavily on wish-fulfillment fantasies, Uglymug, Epicfighter grounds its protagonist in a harsh reality. Shigeru’s backstory—marked by rejection and betrayal—gives him a relatable edge, and his decision to double down on his “ugly” traits in exchange for power is a fascinating twist. The show’s early episodes, particularly the premiere (“The Birth of Gachi-God”), shine when showcasing Shigeru’s overwhelming strength, animated with WHITE FOX’s signature flair. Scenes of him casually obliterating enemies with a single flick recall One Punch Man’s Saitama, blending humor with jaw-dropping action.

The supporting cast, including Seika (Konomi Inagaki), Seiji (Kento Shiraishi), and Rizu (Maaya Uchida), adds some depth, with hints of complex backstories that could elevate the narrative. The show’s opening theme, “My Way” by TEMPEST, and ending theme, “Bandage” by Miyu Kaneko, are catchy and thematically resonant, amplifying the emotional stakes of Shigeru’s journey. Additionally, the series occasionally lands sharp comedic beats, particularly when Shigeru’s appearance elicits exaggerated reactions from NPCs, poking fun at the genre’s obsession with flawless heroes.

Weaknesses: Missed Opportunities and Tonal Missteps

Despite its bold premise, Uglymug, Epicfighter struggles to capitalize on its potential. The most glaring issue is its reliance on outdated, problematic humor centered on Shigeru’s appearance. The constant jokes about his “ugly” face and weight feel mean-spirited rather than subversive, alienating viewers who might expect a more nuanced take on beauty standards. As noted in reviews, this approach risks reinforcing harmful stereotypes rather than critiquing them, especially for Western audiences sensitive to body-shaming tropes.

The narrative also suffers from tonal inconsistency. While the premise suggests a blend of comedy, action, and social commentary, the execution often feels disjointed. The serious undertones of Shigeru’s past are undermined by slapstick gags, and the fantasy world’s generic design—complete with standard RPG tropes like guilds and quests—lacks the creativity to match the protagonist’s unique arc. The side characters, while promising, are underdeveloped by the season’s midpoint, with their generic archetypes (the righteous leader, the clumsy girl) failing to stand out.

Shigeru’s weakness to female contact, while an interesting gimmick, is underutilized and often played for cheap laughs rather than meaningful conflict. For example, episodes involving Rizu’s accidental touches devolve into repetitive gags, missing opportunities to explore how this limitation shapes Shigeru’s relationships or growth. By Episode 6, with only 156 user votes averaging a 7.0/10 rating, the show’s reception reflects its divisive nature—engaging for some, but failing to sustain momentum for others.

Art and Animation: A Mixed Bag

WHITE FOX delivers solid animation, particularly in action sequences where Shigeru’s godlike powers are on full display. The vibrant fantasy world of Valleria, with its casinos and sprawling landscapes, is visually appealing, though not groundbreaking. However, the character designs, especially Shigeru’s exaggerated “ugly” features, feel like a missed opportunity. The art style doesn’t lean hard enough into stylization to amplify the comedy or commentary, resulting in a middle-of-the-road aesthetic that neither fully embraces absurdity nor subverts expectations.

Reception and Controversy

Fan reactions on platforms like X and review sites highlight the show’s polarizing nature. Some praise its fresh take on isekai, with comments like “comfy and funny” and appreciation for its “ugly bastard” protagonist breaking the mold of handsome MCs. Others, however, criticize its humor as “tired” and “disgusting,” particularly for its reliance on anti-fat tropes. Posts on X reflect similar sentiments, with some calling the show “total trash” and others finding its unique premise “impressionante” but marred by poor pacing and dialogue. The manga, reviewed for its first 10 chapters, received a C+ overall, with critics noting its failure to commit to either comedy or social commentary.

Is It Worth Watching?

Uglymug, Epicfighter Season 1 is a bold experiment that challenges isekai conventions but doesn’t fully deliver on its promise. Its exploration of self-worth and societal bias is commendable, but the reliance on problematic humor and a lack of narrative focus hold it back. Fans of unconventional anime may find it worth a watch for its audacity and action-packed moments, especially if they enjoy series like Solo Leveling or One Punch Man. However, those sensitive to body-shaming or seeking deeper character development may find it lacking.

Final Verdict: 6.5/10
Uglymug, Epicfighter is a unique but uneven addition to the isekai genre. It’s a show that dares to ask big questions but trips over its own execution. If Season 2 leans into its potential for social commentary and refines its humor, it could become a standout. For now, it’s a flawed gem best suited for viewers willing to overlook its rough edges for a fresh perspective.