They Are My Noble Masters Season 1: A Deep Dive into a Polarizing Harem Comedy

They Are My Noble Masters (Kimi ga Aruji de Shitsuji ga Ore de), a 2008 anime adapted from a 2007 visual novel by Minato Soft, is a curious artifact of its era. This 13-episode series, directed by Susumu Kudo and animated by A.C.G.T, dives headfirst into the harem and ecchi genres while attempting to carve out a unique identity through its blend of comedy, character-driven drama, and occasional social commentary. Season 1, which aired from January to March 2008, remains the sole animated adaptation of the visual novel, leaving a legacy that is equal parts entertaining and divisive. This article explores what makes They Are My Noble Masters stand out, its strengths and weaknesses, and why it remains a fascinating, if flawed, entry in the anime landscape.

---

Plot Overview: A Tale of Servitude and Dysfunction

The story follows Ren Uesugi and his older sister Mihato, who flee their abusive father and arrive in a bustling city with little money and fewer prospects. After Ren aids a young girl named Miyu Kuonji, the siblings are hired as a butler and maid at the opulent Kuonji mansion, serving the three Kuonji sisters: Shinra, the sadistic eldest; Miyu, the genius loli NEET; and Yume, the clumsy high schooler with a penchant for accidental panty flashes. The mansion is a chaotic ecosystem of eccentric servants, including Natose, a battle-ready maid with a tragic past, and Taijiri Yasushi, a former special forces head butler with a penchant for theatrics. What ensues is a mix of slapstick comedy, fanservice-heavy antics, and surprisingly poignant character backstories as Ren navigates his new role and the affections of those around him.

Unlike many harem anime that lean heavily on a bland protagonist, They Are My Noble Masters gives Ren a bit more agency. He’s not just a passive recipient of female attention but a determined young man adapting to a bizarre environment while grappling with his traumatic past. The series oscillates between lighthearted humor and heavier themes like abuse, loss, and class disparity, creating a tonal tightrope that doesn’t always hold steady.

---

What Sets It Apart: Unique Elements and Bold Choices

1. Parody and Meta-Humor
   The anime is a treasure trove of references to other works, particularly those featuring its voice actors. For instance, Ren (voiced by Tomokazu Seki) and Colonel Taijiri channel Mobile Fighter G Gundam with exaggerated techniques like “Sekiha Tenkouken” and “Shining Finger.” Shinra’s nod to Hayate no Gotoku in the first episode’s “On the Next” segment acknowledges the show’s place in the butler anime subgenre. These parodies add a layer of self-awareness that keeps the comedy fresh, especially for viewers familiar with the referenced series. The show doesn’t just mimic; it winks at its audience, inviting them to laugh at the absurdity of its tropes.
2. Character-Driven Side Stories
   Unlike many harem anime that prioritize romance or fanservice over depth, They Are My Noble Masters dedicates significant time to exploring its characters’ backstories. Natose’s tragic loss of her family in a tsunami, Shinra’s struggle to live up to her mentor’s expectations, and Ren’s confrontation with his abusive father provide emotional weight. While some reviews criticize these side stories as melodramatic or poorly executed, they offer a glimpse into the characters’ motivations, making them more than one-dimensional archetypes. For example, Natose’s dog-like loyalty and superhuman feats (like leaping to catch a newspaper) are juxtaposed with her vulnerability, creating a compelling contrast.
3. Subtle Class Commentary
   The Kuonji mansion, with its stark divide between the wealthy sisters and their servants, subtly critiques class dynamics. Ren and Mihato’s desperation for work highlights the precariousness of their situation, while the Kuonji sisters’ eccentricities underscore the disconnect between privilege and responsibility. The show doesn’t delve deeply into this theme, but moments like Ren’s employment as a butler despite no prior experience reflect the arbitrary nature of opportunity in a stratified society. This undercurrent adds a layer of substance to an otherwise frivolous premise.
4. Balanced Ensemble Cast
   The Kuonji sisters—Shinra, Miyu, and Yume—each bring distinct personalities that avoid blending into a single “harem blob.” Shinra’s teasing dominance, Miyu’s intellectual aloofness, and Yume’s earnest clumsiness create a dynamic trio. Supporting characters like Benisu, the tsundere maid, and the Colonel, with his over-the-top machismo, further enrich the ensemble. While some reviews note that the characters follow familiar tropes, their vibrant interactions and the voice actors’ enthusiasm elevate them beyond cliché.

---

Strengths: Why It Shines

• Comedy and Energy
  The humor is a standout, blending slapstick, witty banter, and anime parodies into a cohesive package. Episodes like the Colonel drifting a limousine in a CGI art shift or Shinra reenacting a Neon Genesis Evangelion beer scene are absurdly entertaining. The show’s high energy, driven by a talented voice cast (Shizuka Itō, Yuko Goto, Tomokazu Seki), keeps even weaker episodes engaging.
• Character Chemistry
  The interactions between Ren and the Kuonji sisters, as well as the mansion’s other servants, crackle with personality. Whether it’s Shinra’s teasing, Miyu’s deadpan quips, or Mihato’s overprotective sibling instincts, the relationships feel dynamic and lived-in. The show’s ability to balance fanservice with genuine camaraderie is a rare feat in the genre.
• Visual and Audio Flair
  While the animation isn’t groundbreaking, A.C.G.T delivers vibrant character designs and expressive facial animations that enhance the comedy. The opening theme, “Hizamazuku Made 5 Byo Dake!” by Miyuki Hashimoto, is catchy and sets the playful tone, while the closing theme, “Butler Switch On!” by Yuko Goto, captures the show’s cheeky charm.

---

Weaknesses: Where It Stumbles

• Tonal Inconsistency
  The series struggles to balance its comedic and dramatic elements. The shift from fanservice-laden hijinks to heavy topics like Ren’s abusive father or Natose’s tragic past can feel jarring. Some side stories, intended to be poignant, come off as contrived or rushed, undermining their emotional impact. As one review notes, “The stories themselves are usually supposed to be sad and encouraging, however they don’t ever have that effect and are more thought of as ridiculous.”
• Weak Central Plot
  The main storyline—Ren and Mihato’s life as servants—lacks a strong narrative thread. Much of the series is episodic, relying on mini-arcs and character backstories to drive the plot. While this approach allows for character exploration, it leaves the overarching story feeling aimless. The conclusion, squeezed into the final episode’s credits, feels abrupt and unsatisfying.
• Voice Acting Mismatch
  Some viewers found the voice acting, particularly for male characters like Ren and the Colonel, to be grating or mismatched. The high-pitched, “squeaky” delivery doesn’t always convey the intended emotions, which can detract from serious moments.
• Fanservice Overload
  As an ecchi anime, fanservice is expected, but They Are My Noble Masters occasionally overindulges. Scenes like Yume’s frequent panty flashes or Shinra’s teasing can feel gratuitous, alienating viewers who prefer story over spectacle. The incestuous undertones between Ren and Mihato, while played for laughs, may discomfort some audiences.

---

Critical Reception: A Mixed Bag

The anime has garnered a range of opinions. On MyAnimeList, it holds a weighted mean score of 7.22/10, with 65 users voting it a “masterpiece” and only one deeming it “worst ever.” This suggests a generally positive reception among fans of the genre. However, reviews highlight both its charm and its flaws:

• Positive Takes: Fans praise the show’s humor, vibrant characters, and self-aware tone. One reviewer on Anime-Planet called it “a more mature Hayate no Gotoku,” appreciating its restraint compared to sillier contemporaries. The ensemble cast and parodies are frequently cited as highlights.
• Negative Critiques: Detractors point to the weak plot and tonal inconsistency. AniDB’s review notes that the main story is “weak and stupid,” with side stories failing to evoke the intended emotions. Some also find the characters too archetypal, despite their unique quirks.

Compared to Hayate no Gotoku, a similar butler-themed harem anime, They Are My Noble Masters is often seen as less polished but more daring in its mature themes and humor. However, it lacks the narrative cohesion and broader appeal of its rival.

---

Cultural Context and Legacy

Airing in 2008, They Are My Noble Masters arrived during a peak period for harem and ecchi anime, alongside titles like To Love-Ru and Rosario + Vampire. Its roots in an adult visual novel gave it an edge in terms of risqué content, but the anime adaptation toned down explicit elements for TV, making it accessible yet still provocative. The show’s blend of fanservice, comedy, and drama reflects the era’s experimentation with genre boundaries, though its niche appeal limited its mainstream success.

The lack of a second season, despite some fans’ hopes, suggests the series didn’t capture a wide enough audience. Still, its manga adaptation, serialized in Comp Ace, and drama CDs indicate a dedicated fanbase. The anime’s legacy lies in its bold humor and memorable characters, which continue to resonate with fans of the genre.

---

Why It’s Worth Watching

They Are My Noble Masters isn’t a masterpiece, but it’s a fascinating snapshot of its time. Its strengths—sharp comedy, dynamic characters, and clever parodies—make it a fun ride for fans of harem and ecchi anime. The show’s willingness to tackle heavier themes, even imperfectly, sets it apart from more formulaic contemporaries. If you enjoy self-aware humor and don’t mind fanservice or tonal shifts, Season 1 offers a unique blend of chaos and heart.

For those new to the series, approach it with an open mind and a tolerance for early 2000s anime quirks. It’s not Fullmetal Alchemist or Steins;Gate (as MyAnimeList’s top-ranked anime might suggest), but it’s a guilty pleasure with enough depth to keep you engaged.

---

Final Verdict

They Are My Noble Masters Season 1 is a wild, imperfect gem that thrives on its eccentric cast and playful humor but stumbles with a weak plot and inconsistent tone. It’s a love letter to harem anime fans who appreciate meta-humor and character-driven stories, yet it’s not for everyone due to its heavy fanservice and niche appeal. If you’re looking for a nostalgic trip into the 2008 anime scene or a quirky butler comedy, this series delivers—warts and all.

Rating: 7.3/10 – Good, with flashes of brilliance but held back by its flaws.

---

Where to Watch
As of August 2025, They Are My Noble Masters is not available on major streaming platforms like Netflix or Crunchyroll. Check secondary sources like Amazon for DVD releases or fan-subbed versions online, though availability may vary.